Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Law. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 4, 2017

Orange Is the New Black compared to Attica

It's been about 8 months since I've published a blog because of my environment. Last blog was an anticipation to post about my latest adventure to Europe. I did it. I spent a month traveling from New York to Boston then to Iceland, The Netherlands, Germany, The Czech Republic and then to Copenhagen before my flight home back to the New York City. I will likely write about my adventures on that another day.

There are a few topics that interest me. Traveling and culture are of course two subjects. Another two would be survival as a homeless person and the inner system of the prison culture. I'm going to talk about the latter subject.

This topic of the television show Orange Is the New Black comparison to Attica brought up by a friend raises a few interesting topics. My first thought was there must be some correlation between the two. She also mentioned in the subject the book to compare the television show by: Blood in the Water: The Attica Prison Uprising of 1971 and Its Legacy by Heather Ann Thompson.

Orange Is the New Black plots about a Caucasian lady (Piper Chapman played by the actor Taylor Schilling) going to prison from an average, what seems to be middle-class lifestyle. She does some money laundering for some drug dealers/smugglers and is sent to prison. She then has to adapt to prison life and there comes the rest of the cast of female inmates and what happens in Litchfield Prison. Ok, fine, the topics from scenes illustrate properly as the shows category: Comedy-Drama. At some points it will highlight on Lesbianism, violence, race, hierarchy, power struggle, mental health, survival and other prison life subjects BUT here's what makes the show Award Winning: it turns those very real subjects into a huge spin on satire. It turns those real subjects to the point of soap opera in prison for a show based on a non-fictional story line.

In season five one of the episodes during the riot a couple of prisoners started shouting Attica! But briefly after they did that they discussed why they were shouting it. They had no clue, they were just following along with others shouting it. They're not stupid, just a lack a knowledge I guess. I defend their ignorance for a few reasons. I too lacked that knowledge. I didn't know anything about Attica Correctional Facility, until I read the book Blood in the Water,  except it was a well known prison. I figured something big went down there but never sort to research it's history. And it happened 47-48 years ago. It being in history is one thing I learned, the date of it's occurrence. I also learned that what put it in history is the riot and why the riot occurred. I learned that it's still in operation. I had assumed it was closed down for such an old prison.

Does the show compare similarly with the book Blood in the Water or the Attica uprising? I can't compare it the television show with the actual memoirs the show is based on from Piper Kerman's Orange Is the New Black: My Year in a Women's Prison.

Yes, the television show Orange is the New Black has a light similarity to the book Blood in the Water.

-Piper Chapman is sent to prison for a somewhat considerable low-level non-heinous White-collar crime compared to some of the prisoners serving jail time in Attica before the Attica riots were also doing low-level non-heinous Blue-collar crimes. They were sent imprisoned for reasons other than their crime.

-Some of the actions and themes taken place in the show did also occur in Attica prison based on the comments from prisoners in the book such as abuse and sexual misconduct.

-The book and the show sort of give a little story line or description of prisoners and their life inside and out. I like that the show gives scenes relating to the prisoner's earlier life before they were imprisoned. The book gives a very light why prisoners are in jail.

-Racial and hierarchy between prisoners and guards did play a major factor in culture life in both prisons.

-In the show the riot began when one or more (with her associates) of the prisoners lead by prisoner Taystee started a sort of stampede. She was upset over a briefing by the warden defending a guard that killed her other prison friend. In the book, it was stated that the Attica riot began when one of the guards was struck in fear or sort of defense. A certain block of prisoners were being rerouted from one part of the jail to another when one gate had been locked the prisoners were trapped and for one reason or another fear of being trapped in a sort of tunnel caused a prisoner to assault a guard and that's when a single action from a circumstance caused a chain of chaos.

Warning: Spoiler Alert!

-In both themes, negotiations were not fruitful in the immediate future. In the show who knows what will happen if there is a season six. In real life or that is in the aftermath of the Attica riot there were questions on why the outcome with such as forceful raid actually necessary and lawsuits.

-In both there were negotiations (of course different demands). The show had a list of comfort and entertainment negotiation demands while the actual Attica prisoners of 1971 wanted amnesty and fairer treatment.

-In both story lines there was raid or that is a storming of the prison by force. The actual event is said to have had 49 prisoners/hostages lives lost. In season five of the show besides, Poussey dying in season four, two died.

-Both gave a look inside what prison life is like but probably not the whole story, one I would gladly never like to experience.

There's probably more and some details slightly off or not written but just an update on what's currently on my plate.

Tuesday, May 14, 2013

Security Hinders Freedom

...But security maintains order.

In this small aspect: The company I work for has two main entrances: the front and back. Each entrance has a building front desk receptionist and would be security officer manned at the location. All the other side entrances are locked. I'm sure this is the case for all buildings. On a working weekday, people who work in the building can enter and exit at both entrances. However, on the weekends the back entrance is locked because of staffing is only provided infront. I work weekends also and I drive to work. The back entrance is where all the parking is located. It's locked, so on weekends I have to walk all the way around the building with very long streets in order to get into the building. Unfortunate for everyone else that works weekends also has to walk all the way around the building, about two and a half long streets just because of those security (or we can be blame it on staffing) reasons. The fact that the back entrance is locked on the weekends is a deterent that is a hassle to me.

Mid range aspect: About two and a half years ago, I owned a BMW. All modern German (that goes for a handful of other countries as well) cars are required to have an Immobiliser installed. An Immobiliser is basically a electronic device in the car that won't start it if a code in the key doesn't match the encryption in the electronic device in the car. I fount this out the hard way when the Immobiliser light went on as the battery died one winter and I couldn't get a new battery installed for a few days. Basically after a few days when I got the new battery installed the car not having a charge for a few days set off the BMW's Immobiliser. Fortunately for me, the light did go away. However, I have read stories where people could not start their car because of this issue. They had to go to the mandatory trouble of going to the dealer to have a copy of an encrypted key sent from Germany in order to hopefully get their car started again. It's purpose is to deter theft. Yet, sophisticated thieves have fount a way around it. So does the troublesome aspect out weigh the benefit of it's intent? I think it does.

Mass aspect: Airport security can be a bit of a nuisance if you don't learn to keep it simple. I once had a bottle of 32oz Cocoa Butter in my carry-on because I was traveling with a healing injury. The security lady delayed my bag and sent it through again, then explained in a very rude way that such a larger liquid item was not allowed. Yes, the situation wasn't an ordeal but a minor hassle. This was years ago but everyone once in a while, I read in the news of a similar incident where people are harassed or violated of their rights because it doesn't fit into security protocol.

I understand the need for safety to filter out what shouldn't be there but security features only hinder and block freedom to be as we are.

Saturday, October 1, 2011

Incident Report

So, I missed September's post but it's October 1st, close enough.  I'm going to update on an incident that occurred on September 4th, 2011.  It was a quiet Sunday, no one around, when I walked outside from my house to my car. There was a scent in the air, the scent of marijuana. Whether it was coming from me is besides the point and will not be pointed out here due to refusing to self incriminate myself.  It could not have been more than five minutes from lingering on my porch to getting in my car and sitting there for a minute.  During that five minutes, I lit up on my porch and sat there a few minutes and finished it in my car, I think it was a cigarette, I think. It could have been a Bidi.  I sat in my car for a minute, by the time I started my engine I see flashing lights behind me, guess who it is.  Within thirty seconds I have one police officer on my left and another officer telling me to lower my back window on my right passenger side.  I guess someone was around because the driver's side officer tells me someone reported it.

The police officer on my driver's side window on my left does not ask me for my license or registration, he just tells me to turn off the engine and to exit the car.  He then ask me for my license when I am out of the car.  I did not know at the time, but I am reading different statements that I have the right to not leave my car.  But I am also reading that if an officer has suspicion of an illegal activity he does have that right to ask to exit the vehicle, that is if the officer sees an illegal item in your car out in the open, but the scent of marijuana?  But who's to say it's from my car?  None the less, I exited the vehicle and they pat me down.  We are now standing on the back of my car and in front of the police car.  While I am being asked questions by the officer on my driver's side door, the officer that was on my passenger side who asked me to lower my back window is now searching my car, which she leaves a mess.  I was not prepared for any of this, this incident was the first time of this occurrence, but I was not nervous or scared, I just hoped they didn't arrest me.  I answer the questions that the officer asks me.  I know I have the right not to answer, "the right to remain silent".  He asks me questions like do I live alone or do I have any outstanding warrants against me. I answer his questions and she's done searching my car.  They go to the computer in their car, do a little search on my records and let me go.  The final comment from the officer on my driver's side who was questioning me said: "Go home and do it on your own time".  I drove off and got some food.  After the incident: The question that come into mind is the search legal?

www.Legalzoom.com points out that yes, even though I read from other sources that it should not be, it was a legal search.  I did notate the Precinct, Plate Numbers and Name of the officers stopping me.  It is warranted as a legal search because the car does not require a search warrant.  If the officer has a suspicion of illegal activity, they can.  I guess even the scent of an illegal substance.

In Sturgis, South Dakota there is an annual event where thousands, and I don't mean one or two thousand, of motorcycle enthusiast and fanatics come to gather.  It's a big event that bring all types.  The other day they were showing a television show of how police officers handle and keep the peace during this huge event, they needed to recruit additional police personnel from outside departments.  At random check points, a handful of these officers were questioning this driver at random.  It showed that there was no smell, no open narcotics in plain sight, they just decided to pull him over and do a search.  They do find marijuana in the car and they arrest him.  Is this legal?  It was depicted on television.

On September 23rd, 2011, an article by the news network NY1, written by Tetiana Anderson writes:

In response to strong criticism, Police Commissioner Ray Kelly issued an internal order Friday reiterating NYPD policy that an arrest shouldn't be executed if a person has a small amount of marijuana out of public view. NY1’s Tetiana Anderson filed the following report."

Amid complaints about improper arrests, the New York City Police Department is getting a fresh reminder on an old directive. Commissioner Ray Kelly told the city's nearly 35,000 officers that reading people their rights for possessing small amounts of marijuana is a no-no.

"Eight people out of ten probably have weed in their pockets, but it doesn't mean they're criminals. Newports, they're legal, but it's still a drug," says one New Yorker.

"Since 1994, NYPD has enacted stop and frisk practices,” said Cassandra Frederique of the Drug Policy Alliance. “One of the collateral consequences of that have been these marijuana arrests. Last year, there were over 50,000 arrests and most of them were, 84 percent were black and Latino. Seventy percent were under the age of 30."

Kelly reiterated existing department policy, saying officers should actually be issuing tickets for holding small amounts of marijuana that is not in public view.

The move comes after growing criticism of the NYPD from civil liberties and drug policy watchdog groups.

"We at the Drug Policy Alliance are really happy with the commissioner taking this step and asking his police force to follow the original intent of the law,” said Frederique.

And if they do, critics of the NYPD say it could result in tens of thousands fewer marijuana arrests annually, saving the city millions.

In a statement, City Councilman Peter Vallone Jr., the chairman of the city's council on public safety committee said, "Commissioner Kelly's order strikes the proper balance between enforcing the law as passed by the legislature and allowing proper discretion."

Not everyone believes the directive will work.

"That's good, but they're still going to arrest people, ‘cause that's cops. They're gonna do what they do,” said one New Yorker.

The law says possessing 25 grams or less of pot is a non-criminal violation punishable by a fine, but smoking the drug in public or having it visible remains a crime."

Know the law, especially if you tread on it.

-Most important lesson: If there is the scent of marijuana in the air, don't smoke anything, like a cigarette or a bidi in your car or outside.  If you have any or over 25 grams in your house and plan to smoke it, don't smoke it in your house, any scent coming from your house and the neighbors report it can lead to a search.  Over 25 grams will get you jail time.

-Home searches require a search warrant but based on any police suspicion car searches do not require a search warrant.  If you're walking and the police suspect you, based on appearance, your look, or fishy activity it's enough for them to "suspect" and stop, then give you a pat down, which the court determines as not a search. A non-violation of the 4th Amendment which safe guards against unreasonable search and seizure, which is very court defined but when there is a uniform with a gun aggressively by active or verbal force demanding or insisting you to do something, you can plead law but a gun or abuse is in your face is another story.

What about those innocent or the low level marijuana users who use it for recreational purposes. What about the people that use it just to relax or use it to relieve pain.  I was not arrested but I could have been if the officers stopping me had fount even a little bit of marijuana.  I am not a criminal.  I am not drug dealer.  I don't steal.  I have family.  I work my 40 hours a week.  I pay my taxes to feed your police salary.

Fuck off my Freedom.